
Arya News - The significance of this ruling extends well beyond its immediate legal implications. For the first time, the ICJ has found a state responsible for committing genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention.
DHAKA – In a historic judgment delivered on November 19, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) found Myanmar responsible for genocide against its Rohingya population during the military’s brutal 2016–2017 operations in Rakhine State. After years of legal proceedings and nearly a decade of international inaction, the verdict has brought renewed attention to a humanitarian catastrophe that was gradually slipping from the world’s consciousness. The judgment marks a watershed moment in the pursuit of accountability for the atrocities committed against the Rohingya, following a seven-year legal battle initiated by the Gambia in 2019.
The significance of this ruling extends well beyond its immediate legal implications. For the first time, the ICJ has found a state responsible for committing genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention. The case is also remarkable because it was brought by the Gambia, a small West African country with no direct geographical or political stake in the Rohingya crisis, demonstrating how states can invoke international law to uphold collective obligations against genocide. The judgment further acknowledges the scale and systematic nature of the violence, including the killing of thousands of Rohingya civilians, widespread sexual violence and attacks on children, and the “intent to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya population” through acts of ethnic cleansing.
For Bangladesh, which opened its borders to hundreds of thousands of Rohingya fleeing military persecution in 2017, the ruling carries particular significance. It reinforces the international legitimacy of Bangladesh’s humanitarian response and strengthens its diplomatic position in advocating for a durable solution. But what does this judgment mean for the more than one million Rohingya refugees who remain stranded in Bangladesh? More importantly, how can the Rohingya community, the Bangladesh government and the international community translate this legal victory into meaningful political and practical outcomes?
From legal recognition to accountability
The ICJ judgment is legally binding on Myanmar under Article 59 of the Court’s Statute and Article 94(1) of the UN Charter. Myanmar is obliged to comply with the Court’s decision. Under Article 94(2), the Gambia, as the applicant state, can bring alleged non-compliance before the UN Security Council, which may recommend or decide on measures to give effect to the judgment. However, the Court has no independent enforcement mechanism, and the political dynamics of the Security Council, particularly the possibility of a veto, remain significant obstacles.
The judgment also unfolds against an increasingly complicated political landscape in Myanmar. The military government at the centre, the Arakan Army, which now exercises de facto control over substantial parts of Rakhine State, the epicentre of the Rohingya genocide, and the exiled National Unity Government (NUG), largely led by exiled politicians from Aung San Suu Kyi’s National League for Democracy (NLD), represent different centres of political and military power. Their positions and responses to the judgment will have important implications for the Rohingya’s future. The Arakan Army, in particular, cannot be excluded from any discussion of protection, rights and eventual repatriation, given its growing territorial influence and reported abuses against Rohingya communities.
It is too early to predict how these actors will respond. Nevertheless, one principle is now unmistakable: any authority exercising power in Myanmar must take the ICJ judgment into account when addressing issues concerning the Rohingya. Equally important will be how the joint dissenting opinion, in which the judges questioned whether the evidence established genocide, is invoked by actors seeking to challenge, dilute or evade compliance with the Court’s ruling. How this dissent is interpreted and deployed in the political discourse surrounding the verdict warrants close attention.
What can the Rohingya community leverage?
For the Rohingya, the verdict offers something that decades of persecution and displacement have denied them: authoritative international recognition of their suffering and the crimes committed against them. This recognition must now become a source of political agency. Rohingya refugees, community organisations and diaspora networks should seize this moment to amplify their collective voice. They can use the judgment to demand protection, equal rights and freedom from discrimination in countries of asylum, including Malaysia, Indonesia and India, where Rohingya refugees continue to experience precarious legal status, exclusion and, in some instances, hostility.
Rohingya representatives must also become more visible and well organised in international discussions concerning their future. Their demands must not be reduced to physical return alone. The judgment should strengthen their advocacy for citizenship, political recognition, freedom of movement and meaningful participation in decisions about repatriation. The Rohingya diaspora can also help preserve this international political momentum, mobilise legal and human rights networks, document continuing violations and press governments to support the implementation of the judgment. Above all, the community must ensure that international recognition does not become another symbolic victory detached from realities on the ground.
What can Bangladesh do differently?
For Bangladesh, the verdict presents a momentous diplomatic opportunity. Dhaka should seize this renewed international attention to reinvigorate burden-sharing discussions, mobilise sustained humanitarian assistance and actively place the Rohingya crisis on the international agenda. The judgment provides a stronger legal and moral foundation for insisting that the crisis cannot be treated merely as a refugee management challenge for Bangladesh. The government should also intensify diplomatic engagement with relevant international actors, including the UN Security Council, the General Assembly, the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation and regional powers. It should work closely with the Gambia and other states to maintain pressure on Myanmar to fulfil its legal obligations. The judgment should feature prominently in every relevant international forum where Bangladesh raises the Rohingya issue.
However, Dhaka must approach repatriation with strategic caution. The changing power dynamics in Rakhine State mean that engagement cannot be confined to Myanmar’s military authorities. Bangladesh needs a realistic diplomatic strategy that considers the Arakan Army’s growing influence, the position of the National Unity Government and the role of regional actors.
A historic opening, not the end of the struggle
The ICJ judgment is undoubtedly a landmark achievement, but it should not be mistaken for an immediate resolution of the Rohingya crisis. The gap between legal accountability and political implementation remains considerable. Myanmar’s ongoing conflict, the absence of a credible political transition and the limited enforcement capacity of international institutions all make the road ahead uncertain.
Yet, for the first time, the international community has moved beyond acknowledging the Rohingya’s suffering to establishing state responsibility for genocide through the world’s highest court. This is a powerful foundation on which to build.
The challenge now is to ensure that the verdict does not become another historic declaration without meaningful consequences. Bangladesh must turn its renewed diplomatic leverage into a coherent international strategy, while the Rohingya community must use this moment to assert its rights and shape its own future. There are reasons for cautious optimism: the legal and moral case for justice has never been stronger. Whether this moment becomes a turning point will ultimately depend on the political will of states to translate the Court’s judgment into accountability, protection and, eventually, a safe and dignified return home for the Rohingya.
Dr Anas Ansar is a senior researcher at the Arnold Bergstraesser Institute, University of Freiburg, Germany, and an assistant professor in the Department of Political Science and Sociology at North South University (currently on leave).
Read More:
‘Justice is finally being served’: Rohingya widow hears Myanmar genocide ruling from refugee camp
Myanmar guilty of genocide against Rohingya, says top UN court
Reactions as top UN court finds Myanmar guilty of genocide against Rohingya
Explainer: How is genocide proven in court?
Bangladesh welcomes ICJ verdict on Rohingya genocide
Myanmar guilty of genocide. But who will enforce the verdict?